Mediapost Travel Editorial: RTB is the Real Deal

February 8th, 2010

Re-purposing from today’s Mediapost, where I talk about how this in vogue buzzword actually has some dollars-to-doughnuts meaning for travel advertisers.

Real-Time Bidding Is The Real Deal

You gotta love the perennial ad industry buzzword cycle. It helps ad folks like me sound smarter than we really are, but for most it just creates annoying distractions that garner a lot of undeserved attention (social media advertising has a great knack for doing that).

I’m here to tell you that this buzzword’s the real deal, folks. And for travel industry advertisers, “real-time bidding” (RTB) presents the biggest potential to boost advertising efficiency since Google AdWords came along. Here’s how it works:

Today, most of us buy ad network impressions in bulk. We buy into a particular channel, but for the most part the information we have about the individual browsers is in aggregate. They’re in-market travelers. Great.

In reality, when you dig, there are in-market travelers that are traveling in six months, and there are in-market travelers that need to travel tomorrow. There are travelers who want to go to Bali for three weeks (in business class), and there are travelers that want to drive to a motel for one night. With most ad network buys, you’re getting all of these user intent profiles, and you’re paying the same amount to target each of them.

These profiles clearly aren’t worth the same. I bet that United Airlines would pay a lot more to convert the guy who needs a last-minute (and thus full-fare) ticket than the budget-conscious tire kicker who is comparison shopping six months out. The airline has these data from cookies that get dropped when users perform searches on its own site, but without RTB, it bids the same for each of these profiles when it re-targets them across the web. Because not every bid is high enough, sometimes the airline loses and somebody else’s ad shows up on a given impression when it could have been a United ad, if it had just bid higher for that impression.

RTB lets advertisers do just that: define a set of parameters under which they’re willing to pay more, or less, for a given profile. And it’s not that hard, thanks to a few really talented folks who have founded companies around this practice (see: AppNexus, Invite Media, MediaMath, et al.).

They manage your media buy and can adjust bidding — in real time — as a result of the factors that matter to you. All the work is done for you, transparently, and you get a neat report at the end of it all that shows you how many more conversions you generated as a result.

Just be careful when choosing a vendor (referred to as Demand-Side Platforms; “DSPs” — yes another buzzword!). They’re largely based on “black box” optimization engines that don’t really explain themselves well. Get references, and test against a baseline. And then enjoy that extra revenue gained by more efficient media buying!

pknegten Press

UPDATE: “Fixing Advertising” Panel adds Invite Media & AppNexus

February 8th, 2010

Our free (and full bar) shindig just got two more (and final) panelists, Zach Weinberg, Co-founder @ Invite Media and Brian O’Kelley, CEO @ AppNexus.  So, the final details:

Panelists:
Emily Scott, Director of Digital Marketing at Kayak
Mark Mannino, VP Supply at MediaMath
Brad King, Managing Director of Strategic Development at BlueKai
Jon Aizen, COO at Dapper
Zach Weinberg, Co-Founder at Invite Media
Brian O’Kelley, CEO at AppNexus

Our moderator is Sara Holoubek, President of SEMPO NY and CEO of Luminary Labs.

We’ll be pressing the panelists to teach us what all this real-time bidding, advanced user intent, and dynamic ad mumbo-jumbo really means for those of us concerned with getting direct response performance out of our ads. With the traditional ad network model losing a lot of ground to DSPs, it’s certainly an exciting time to be an advertiser or agency and this panel should give everyone a great overview of how to start benefiting from this shift in power.

Drinks still on us.

Just click here to register!

pknegten Conferences, Events

Podcast Episodes 7 & 8: Vish Makhijani @ Zynga and Yaron Galai @ Outbrain

February 4th, 2010

Ahoy, Podcast fans! Just went live with the first episode in 2010, with Yaron Galai, founder and CEO of Outbrain, as well as the founder of Quigo way back when.

We get into what life must be like for the newly independent AOL, discuss arbitrage-based ad networks (and their new challenges), and what he’s up to at Outbrain.

And before I forget, I recorded this great episode with Vish Makhijani, COO of Zynga (and former CEO of Yandex Labs) late last year that I don’t want you to miss.  He’s got some great insights on social media advertising that I think you’ll really like!

Listen to them both here

(no iTunes or don’t want to listen to it there? Here.)

pknegten Podcast

NYC Panel: DSPs, Data, Dynamic Ads – the “new” data driven ecosystem

February 2nd, 2010

Dapper will be hosting a free panel & full bar in NYC Wednesday, February 24th on the ‘new’ ad ecosystem of DSPs, Intent Data, and Dynamic Ads entitled “Fixing Advertising: The New Data-Driven Display Ecosystem.”

Panelists include:
Emily Scott, Director of Digital Marketing at Kayak
Mark Mannino, VP Supply at MediaMath
Brad King, Managing Director of Strategic Development at BlueKai
Jon Aizen, COO at Dapper

UPDATE: Zach Weinberg, co-founder at Invite Media will be joining the panel

Our moderator is Sara Holoubek, President of SEMPO NY and CEO of Luminary Labs.

We’ll be pressing the panelists to teach us what all this real-time bidding, advanced user intent, and dynamic ad mumbo-jumbo really means for those of us concerned with getting direct response performance out of our ads.  With the traditional ad network model losing a lot of ground to DSPs, it’s certainly an exciting time to be an advertiser or agency and this panel should give everyone a great overview of how to start benefiting from this shift in power.

Oh…and did I mention drinks are on us?

Just click here to register!

pknegten Conferences

Dapper COO to Speak at OMMA Global

February 1st, 2010

Our own Jon Aizen will be speaking on Cory Triffiletti’s panel, “How are Buyers and Planners Using Behavioral Targeting to Optimize Results for Clients?” So far he’ll be joining Paul Santello, SVP Brand Sales and Marketing at Evolve Media Group; more updates to come!

pknegten Behavioral Advertising, Conferences

TC: Blippy = Beacon Executed Properly?

January 20th, 2010

Good analysis of the potential of Blippy in TechCrunch this week about how Blippy might just be the way Beacon should have been.  I’ve argued before that if executed properly, Beacon would have been a game-changing advertising channel that would have effectively created intent high up in the funnel for advertisers.

I think Blippy is a bit different though, in that it’s user modulated.  In order to prevent inundating your friends with needless data about your spending behavior, there needs to be just the type of content discovery and filtering system that Facebook is best at (see: News Feed).  Perhaps Blippy will catch on to that and the obtrusiveness will be minimal, which would be a win for retailers.

I’ll argue this again though: if we find a way to cut in consumers in this equation (”if we can publish this transaction, you get 1% back”) this could be a much more valuable channel.

Just some food for thought…

pknegten Social Advertising

2010 Season of Advertising Sucks (and the People Who Fix It) Podcast!

January 11th, 2010

Hey folks!

Hope everyone had a great new year; I want to ring ours in with a new season of Advertising Sucks (and the People Who Fix It) podcast that is sure to be even more informative, helpful, and entertaining as last year.  Thanks to all our 2009 guests, and we’ll be welcoming some new ones from our friends at MediaMath, Outbrain, and others.  Stay tuned!

Listen to last season here

(no iTunes or don’t want to listen to it there? Here.)

pknegten Podcast

The Opposite of Dynamic Ads

December 16th, 2009

I’m excited at the possibilities and opportunities a free AOL has in store for the display ad business.  However, as I read foreboding articles about the end of hand-crafted content, I see the other side’s point a bit.

Seed is radical.  It pushes content authors toward topics that have the most demand for advertising among AOL’s client set.  This is a much different approach to demand-side optimization than we’ve seen with algorithmic based DSPs so far.  I applaud their ingenuity.

However, I think they’re missing an opportunity with live, unbridled content.  Thing is, there’s value to off-topic ideas, thoughts, and editorials.  Beyond the fact that data beyond the page may exist that can target advertising pretty effectively, the point of dynamic ads is that a given set of advertisers can have so many variations of their ad that if one article doesn’t work for a particular pitch, it just might work for any of a million others.  And if no match is found for a particular advertiser at all, it’s undoubtedly found among the near-unlimited ad inventory presented by many dynamic ads from many advertisers (something AOL would have).

pknegten General

Speaking at “Tech Trends in ‘10″ at Bloomberg Today

December 10th, 2009

I’ll be joining some esteemed contemporaries from the ad world today in a panel @ Bloomberg in NYC moderated by Colin Gillis.  The panel is called “Evolution in Internet Advertising” at approximately 4pm if you can make it!

Others on the panel are Michael Barrett of AdMeld, Andy Monfried of Lotame.  Looking forward to it!

Update: This will be a live webcast.  Watch it here.

pknegten Conferences

Is Display Catching Up to Search?

December 8th, 2009

Great overview (and Dapper mention) by Josh Dreller in Search Engine Land of the display landscape, from DSPs to dynamic creative and everything in between.  Read it here.

pknegten Press